Dump the Smith. I have 220s from when a 220 was not even Sig but Browning to a month ago. Or dump both for Les Baer or CZ Dan Wesson 1911.

 

I agree with the person that posted to keep both if you can since the S&W is out of production. If you really had to choose, the 220 is the better firearm hands down. Yeah, you can always get another but you stuck with an inferior 45.

 

Why are you selling? If you need the money, sell both. If they are almost unfired, you clearly dont prefer either.

 

It's partially the money and now that I'm old I'm trying to thin the herd. I only keep the Glock because of the extra capacity. But I don't need 2 stainless 45's with double action. Those who love Smith's door stop heavy guns say keep the 645, but the machining is rough. The Sig is W German frame but it's really hard to rack the slide, it's so stiff. I like 'em both but they are too heavy and bulky to carry every day, and only 9 rounds not worth it.

 

neither. but if I had a choice I'd sell the P220. they're reasily replaceable and the 645 is a hard thing to find these days

 

If decided to let one go, see which is sold first. How could I tell you what to sell?!… mho 😎

 

The Question should probably be which one do you shoot better or which one do you like better? I would probably keep the 220 or sell them both and buy a custom 1911.

 

No need to try a caliber failure. Don't like Gaston's dreams anyway.

 

The Sig has more support (for now) and certainly more aftermarket.

 

^^^^^^^^ this.