My money is on the Glock 20. You wouldn’t think that a light polymer frame would be good at taming recoil but my G20 does amazing well. Same with its .45acp counter part, the G21. Less felt recoil than my Sig P220 in .45
I think the P220 10mm is a pretty easy shooter, and I like to shoot the hot stuff.
I don't consider my G20 Gen 4 to be a soft shooter, not by a long shot. But it is manageable. My only problem is my G20 just doesn't fit my hand well. The grip doesn't fit as well as my FNX-45 with 15 rounds of .45ACP in the grip.
I have three P220/10 and used to have a G20. To me the mass of the 220 outdoes the flex of the G20. But it's not obvious one way or the other. Now, my philosophy is that if you are not going to load up to the full power design loads of the 10mm don't bother with it - save your money and get a .40 or 9. The recoil of the 10mm fully loaded really is not a problem and I never understood why the FBI dropped it so quickly. I would not choose my weapon based upon how soft it shoots, rather how I intend to use it. For me that's pigs and deer and bear backup.
A forum community dedicated to SIG Sauer Pistols and SIG Sauer Rifles owners and enthusiasts. Come join the discussion about optics, hunting, gunsmithing, styles, reviews, accessories, classifieds, and more!