Pocket Pistol Recommendation

coppertop004 said:

I'm currently sporting a North American Arms mini-revolver as my pocket pistol option. I like the little gun, can hit what I need to from about 10 yards away, but wouldn't mind something a little larger. But not too larger.

Something between a Ruger LCP Max and the North American Arms?

Looked at the Berettas and the only downside is the weight. Same can be said about the North American Arms Guardians.

I've got a Baby Browning but the slide bite is terrible. Not an issue if your life depended on it but sucks when spending time on the range with this little fella. Thought about the Seecamp, but they are pricey and hard to find. Not a big fan of a two-shot derringer. I've got a H&R 22 Mag that I carried as a back-up (or coat gun) on the job, but not sure it should fly solo.

I like the Kahr .380 but have a bad history with Kahr firearms. The LCP Max is growing on me but I'd like to go a bit smaller and the prices around here have gone through the roof. Hard to find one under $500 in my neck of the woods. I don't mind paying $500 for a gun but not for one that should be priced in the $350 range.

So I toss it to you guys. What's out there that is larger than the North American Arms mini-revolvers but smaller than a LCP Max? It could be a revolver or semi-auto. Kinda thinking the Beretta (either 21a or 3032) is the best option and I just have to live with the weight. What am I missing?

Click to expand...

Adopt some loose fit black cargo pants/shorts with a roomy front pocket and shove a P365 chambered in 9mm in a pocket holster.

It's only a little bigger than an LCP MAX and is so much more gun. Or if your wrists aren't up to the recoil of 9mm out of a 3 inch barrel and a tiny grip there's the 380 version.

It is a little bulky for pocket carry, and is about as big as it gets and still work for me. But if I have something on me it's usually a P365 in my front right pocket. It's not as easy to shoot as my larger 9mm handguns. A little snappy. But put a stiff wrist behind it and it shoots like a bigger gun.

I actually went out looking for Kel-tec P3AT, Bodyguard 380 and was considering an LCP II when the LGS handed me a P365 and ended up buying one. I still wouldn't mind something smaller for the pants whose pockets don't hide the P365 as well. At the same time, most folks probably think it's a fat wallet or something.

If I were to look at something smaller than my P365 today it would probably be between the LCP II, Bodyguard 380 or maybe even a P938. Or the P238 if 9mm out of a short barrel is too much for someone's wrists.

My cajunized CZ Rami is slightly larger than my Sig 365 and far more accurate. It also fits in a Sticky pocket holster very well.

2 targets both at 12 yards. One point and shoot (no sights) fast as I can the other with sights

I too have a North American Arms mini-revolver in .22 Magnum. It's the pistol that I carry when I absolutely can't carry anything larger. It's only good at "bad breath" distances and I would only use it to break contact with an attacker in order to get to something bigger and more effective.
That's the way I feel about most "pocket" or deep concealment pistols, unless they are 9mm/.38 Special +P or greater, of which there are not many. If you're inclined toward the P365 (after all, this is a SIG forum), go with the 9mm. You can also get the manual safety version if a striker fired pistol in your pocket, or appendix carry, concerns you. I regularly carry a P365MS when more than just casual concealment is necessary.
A S&W J-frame revolver in .38 Special +P, such as the Model 442/642 (I carry a 442) or any of the Airweight or Scandium frame models would also work. I don't recommend any of the .357 magnum versions like the 340PD. They're the same frame size as a .38 Special +P, but you'll end up with .38 Special ammo in it after the first time you try .357 magnum loads.
I had a P938 at one time, but didn't care for carrying it cocked and locked in a pocket/appendix carry. Carrying it in Condition 2 (chamber loaded/hammer down) requires cocking the hammer during a stressful situation, and due to the size of the hammer, which is necessarily small on a small pistol, this too became problematic. The same can be said for the P238, plus it's a .380.
What works for me may not work for you. Good luck in your search.

Works great in my Carhartt bibs pocket.